Restoring Leadership: Have We Bought the Wrong Definition?
There's a mug I remember drinking my morning coffee from on a trip to Montana. It has one word on it: Restore. I've been reflecting on that word, and on a question that won't leave me alone: What is leadership, actually?

Not what the books say. Not what the conference stage says. What is it, really?
Because if I'm honest, I think our culture has quietly settled the question for us. We measure leaders by what they know, the title on the door, the money they control, how many people follow them, and the list of things they've accomplished. Knowledge. Position. Money. Popularity. Accomplishment. That's become the scoreboard.
And when that's the scoreboard, leadership turns into something else. It becomes a transaction of content: I give you information, you give me attention. It becomes a victory lap: look at what I built. It becomes purchasing power: I can make things happen because I can pay for them.
I've been in leadership a long time. I've sat in rooms with CEOs, coaches, athletes, missionaries, mayors, and pastors. I've felt the pull of every one of those measures in my own heart. So this isn't a critique from the outside. It's a confession from the inside.
The Blend We Didn't Notice
My doctoral research focused on what I called "blended ideologies": the way capitalism has shaped our Christian theology of work. Not just how we do our jobs, but what we believe about why we work, what makes work valuable, and who we are when we do it. What I found is that the blending is rarely loud. It's subtle. It seeps in. Over time the assumptions of the market start to feel like the assumptions of the Kingdom, and we can't tell the difference anymore.
Here's what I can't stop thinking about: What if the same thing has happened to our definition of leadership?
What if, without ever deciding to, we've let the market tell us what a leader is? Growth is the proof. Scale is the reward. Visibility is the validation. The leader is the one at the top of the org chart with the biggest platform and the best numbers.
And what if, somewhere along the way, we've drifted from what God actually designed leadership to be? If so, the answer isn't a better technique. It's restoration.
"It Shall Not Be So Among You"
Jesus saw this coming. When the mother of James and John came asking for the best seats in the Kingdom, Jesus gathered His disciples and drew a line:
"You know that the rulers of the Gentiles lord it over them, and their great ones exercise authority over them. It shall not be so among you. But whoever would be great among you must be your servant, and whoever would be first among you must be your slave, even as the Son of Man came not to be served but to serve, and to give his life as a ransom for many." (Matthew 20:25–28, ESV)
It shall not be so among you. That isn't a tweak to the world's model. It's a different model altogether. The world measures greatness by how many people serve you. Jesus measures it by how many people you serve.
So What Is It?
The best definitions I've found keep coming back to one word: influence. Michael Anthony, James Estep, and Kevin Gushiken describe biblical leadership as a dynamic process in which someone with God-given capacity influences a specific group toward God's purposes.1 John Piper frames it even more pointedly: a person is a Christian leader to the degree that they exert Christian influence in Christian ways, shaping others toward the image of Christ.2
I love that, because it takes leadership out of the corner office. A mom at the kitchen table, a foreman on a job site, a teacher, a coach, a small group host: anyone who influences others toward God's purposes is leading. Title is optional. Influence isn't.
Here's how I'd say it:
Leadership is influence that moves ourselves and others toward God's purposes.
Notice the word ourselves. You can't lead people somewhere you aren't going.
Look at the Words
Scripture's own vocabulary for leadership tells the story. In the Hebrew Scriptures we meet the nagid (leader or chief), the zaqen (elder), the shophet (judge), the kohen (priest), the nabi (prophet), the melek (king), and the hakam (sage). In the New Testament we meet the presbyteros (elder), the poimēn (shepherd), the episkopos (overseer), the diakonos (servant), and the apostolos (one who is sent).1
Read that list again. Shepherd. Servant. Elder. Sage. One who is sent.
There's no CEO in there. No influencer. No brand.
The sage is especially striking to me. David Pettus describes the hakam as one who fears the Lord and has an understanding that leads to effective moral action.3 Biblical wisdom isn't how much you know. It's knowing God and letting that knowing show up in how you live. That's the opposite of leadership as a transaction of content.
Toward What?
If leadership is influence toward God's purposes, then everything hinges on the next question: What are God's purposes?
Scripture gives us a pretty clear picture.
To bear His image. We are made in the image of God (Genesis 1:26–28). We are His representatives. People should be able to look at a human life and catch a glimpse of what God is like.4 That means every person you lead carries incomparable worth, not because of their skills or productivity, but because of whose image they bear. People are never a means to an end.
To steward, not exploit. God gave humanity dominion over creation (Genesis 1:28). But dominion in God's design is care, not extraction. A leader's job isn't to use up people and resources to hit a number. It's to leave them more whole, more fruitful, and more alive than we found them. That's restoration, not extraction.
To be transformed. God's purpose is to conform us to the image of His Son (Romans 8:29). We are His workmanship, created in Christ Jesus for good works He prepared in advance (Ephesians 2:10). The goal of leadership isn't bigger output. It's people becoming more like Jesus, starting with the leader.
To glorify Him. We were created for His glory (Isaiah 43:7), and whatever we do, we do it all for the glory of God (1 Corinthians 10:31). Not our glory. That ends the victory lap before it starts.
To do justice, love kindness, and walk humbly with God (Micah 6:8). Humility isn't a leadership technique. It's a posture before God.
To love God and love our neighbor (Matthew 22:37–40), and to make disciples (Matthew 28:19–20). Every leader, in the end, is in the people-formation business.
That all would know Him (1 Timothy 2:3–4; John 17:3). Eternal life is knowing God. The highest form of influence is pointing someone toward Him.
A Different Scoreboard
So here's where I land this morning.
If leadership is influence toward God's purposes, the scoreboard changes.
The question isn't "How much do I know?" but "Is my knowing leading to faithful action?"
Not "What's my title?" but "Who am I serving?"
Not "How much can I spend?" but "Am I stewarding or consuming?"
Not "How many people follow me?" but "Are the people around me looking more like Jesus?"
Not "Look what I did" but "Look what God is doing."
That's a harder scoreboard. It doesn't fit neatly on a résumé or in a stage introduction. But it's the one Jesus kept.
I'm asking myself these questions this morning. Maybe you'll ask them with me:
- Whose definition of leadership have I been living by?
- Where has the market's scoreboard crept into my heart?
- Who am I actually influencing, and toward what?
It shall not be so among you. That's still the invitation.
And it's an invitation to be restored. "He restores my soul" (Psalm 23:3, ESV). "Restore to me the joy of your salvation" (Psalm 51:12, ESV). Restoration is God's work before it is ever ours. Maybe that's where leadership begins again: not with a better strategy or a bigger platform, but with a leader whose own soul has been restored, influencing others toward the One who is making all things new (Revelation 21:5).
So here's my prayer this morning: Lord, restore leadership to what You designed it to be. And start with me.
— Troy
Notes
- Michael J. Anthony, James Riley Estep Jr., and Kevin M. Gushiken, Leadership Essentials for Christian Ministries: A Practical Guide for Those Called to Serve (Grand Rapids, MI: Baker Academic, 2026), 18–20.
- John Piper, Sermons from John Piper (1980–1989) (Minneapolis, MN: Desiring God, 2007).
- David Pettus, "A Concept Study: Leadership in Old Testament Hebrew," in Biblical Leadership: Theology for the Everyday Leader, Biblical Theology for the Church (Grand Rapids, MI: Kregel, 2017), 39.
- Tyler Hansen and E. Lund, Napkin Theology: Small Drawings about Big Ideas (New York, NY: Cascade Books, 2023).
Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway. Used by permission. All rights reserved.